tl;dr - only small percentage are stuck on iOS 5.1; everyone is going to need iOS 6 jailbreak; stop being impatient; if Apple patches it independently, pod2g can still release for 5.1
Mr. pod2g must be getting awfully close to a breakthrough in his latest vulnerability-exploiting jailbreak pioneer. Close enough, in fact, to post a poll on his blog as to whether or not he should release it for iOS 5.1, the current version, or wait until iOS 6 (which will likely be unveiled at this year’s WWDC). On one hand, you have a brand-new version of iOS to which everyone with an iDevice is going to want to update, along with the potential of jailbreaking on it. On the other hand, you have the amalgamation of users who either cannot downgrade or jailbreak 5.1 on their A5 devices, are using a tethered 5.1 jailbreak on A4 devices, purchased an iPhone or iPod with 5.1 preinstalled, or purchased an iPad 3, which only comes with 5.1; all of whom could have their situation resolved by a 5.1 jailbreak.
I think the answer is clear: save it for iOS 6.
Let’s not forget that most of us who have been on the jailbreak train for a while made the intelligent decision NOT to update to 5.1. iPhone 4S devices on 5.0.1 are still jailbreakable and untetherable. Every 4S on 5.1 was either accidentally updated, sent away for repair, or purchased well after Absinthe was released. What percentage of jailbreakers (or those who were before getting updated) does that really include? What percentage of individuals would actually benefit from this fabled 5.1 jailbreak? And which jailbroken 5.0.1 users would actually spend the time backing up their stuff, restoring, loading it all back on, and reinstalling all their Cydia goodies for the sake of a single-point update? (Maybe it’s just me, but I wouldn’t.)
Then comes the “Let’s just wait until iOS 7 then! Or iOS 10!” That’s missing the point entirely. Let’s think about both options for the moment. In the short run, a very small handful of potential jailbreakers would actually benefit from a 5.1 jailbreak. In the long run, no one would, as it would be nicely patched in time for iOS 6. If it were decided to hold off until iOS 6, those stuck on 5.1 would be, in the short run, inconvenienced for a few months, but rewarded in the long run (along with the ENTIRE community, including those not “stuck!”) for waiting.
Most people who voted for “release it now” instead of “wait for iOS 6” made their decisions purely based on impatience rather than common sense. Doesn’t matter how much better iOS 6 will be; they want jailbreak NOW. Don’t forget—and this one mainly goes out to pod2g himself—but the beggars/pleaders/whiners are going to pour out of the woodwork the very moment iOS 6 goes live, and there will be just as much (if not more) work to be done to develop a working jailbreak for it. Only this time, it won’t be just The Dude Whose Girlfriend Accidentally Updated His Phone While He Went To Take A Dump waiting for the release; it will be the entire community of jailbreakers.
And finally, there is the possibility of Apple having discovered the exploits independently and having them already patched in iOS 6. The few people who voted “release it now” for a reason other than personal impatience have been referring to this possibility as a “risk.” I’m having a lot of trouble figuring out where there is any sort of risk involved in holding onto this release. Imagine Tim Cook is cheerfully wrapping up his WWDC keynote address this year, as the iOS 6 developer beta goes live on the Apple Developer portal. Our good friend pod2g grabs it and takes a look, only to be sorely disappointed to find out that a number of the vulnerabilities he’s been playing with over the past few weeks have been stomped out. Can he not just polish up his working 5.1 jailbreak and post it anyway? Not everyone loves being on the bleeding edge of beta Apple software. Not to mention, Apple’s developer previews often remain in beta for a good three months. Isn’t this “risk” really just an emotional manifestation of “man i’d be pissd as hell if pod2g waited n then it was patched anyway id feel so screweed in th ass 4 havig 2 wate”?
I know how hard it is to wait for a jailbreak release. I make a personal effort to never buy an iOS device unless it is either already out of jail, or I am certain that it is jailbreakable. I was real mad when I pulled my iPad out of the box and found that it was 3.2.2. It wasn’t until limera1n came out that I was finally able to jailbreak.